When it comes to choosing a toilet for your bathroom, one of the first decisions you’ll face is whether to go with an elongated toilet vs round. This choice can significantly impact your bathroom’s comfort, space, and aesthetic appeal. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore the differences between elongated and round toilets, weighing the pros and cons of each to help you make an informed decision.
Understanding the Basics
Elongated Toilets
Elongated toilets feature an oval-shaped bowl that is typically about two inches longer than a round bowl. This extra length provides additional surface area, which can translate into a more comfortable seating experience for many users. Elongated toilets are often preferred in modern bathrooms due to their sleek and contemporary look.
Round Toilets
Round toilets, on the other hand, have a more traditional design with a circular bowl. They are generally more compact than elongated toilets, making them a popular choice for smaller bathrooms or powder rooms where space is at a premium. The round shape can also be seen as more classic or traditional, fitting well with certain interior design styles.
Pros and Cons
Comfort
Elongated Toilets: The elongated design offers greater seating comfort due to the increased surface area. This can be particularly beneficial for adults and individuals with mobility issues, providing better support and stability. The ergonomic shape of the elongated bowl can also make sitting and rising easier.
Round Toilets: While round toilets may not offer the same level of comfort as elongated models, they are still perfectly functional and can be more comfortable for children and smaller adults. The round shape can be easier for kids to use, making it a suitable option for family bathrooms.
Space Considerations
Elongated Toilets: Due to their longer design, elongated toilets require more space. This can be a limiting factor in smaller bathrooms, where every inch counts. When installing an elongated toilet, you need to ensure that there is enough clearance in front of and around the toilet for comfortable use.
Round Toilets: The compact design of round toilets makes them ideal for small bathrooms and tight spaces. They typically fit better in smaller floor plans, leaving more room for other fixtures and movements. This space-saving feature can be a significant advantage in apartments, older homes, or any bathroom with limited square footage.
Aesthetic Appeal
Elongated Toilets: Elongated toilets often have a more modern and streamlined appearance, making them a popular choice for contemporary bathroom designs. The elongated shape can add a touch of elegance and sophistication to the bathroom, enhancing its overall aesthetic.
Round Toilets: Round toilets tend to have a more traditional look, which can complement classic or vintage bathroom styles. Their simple and compact design can blend seamlessly with various decor themes, providing a timeless appeal.
Cost
Elongated Toilets: Generally, elongated toilets are slightly more expensive than their round counterparts. The higher cost can be attributed to the increased material used in manufacturing the longer bowl and the perceived added comfort and modern design.
Round Toilets: Round toilets are typically more budget-friendly, making them an attractive option for those looking to save money on bathroom fixtures. Their lower cost does not mean lower quality, as many round toilets offer excellent performance and durability.
Installation and Maintenance
Elongated Toilets: Installation of an elongated toilet may require more careful planning to ensure there is adequate space. Additionally, the longer bowl can make cleaning slightly more challenging, as there is a larger surface area to maintain.
Round Toilets: The compact size of round toilets often makes installation easier and more straightforward, especially in tight spaces. Cleaning and maintenance can also be more manageable due to the smaller bowl size.
Special Considerations
Accessibility and ADA Compliance
For bathrooms designed to be accessible to individuals with disabilities, elongated toilets are often preferred. Their design can better accommodate users with mobility issues, providing greater comfort and ease of use. Many elongated models meet the standards set by the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), making them a suitable choice for public restrooms and homes with elderly or disabled residents.
Children’s Bathrooms
In bathrooms primarily used by children, round toilets can be more practical. The smaller, more compact design can be easier for children to use independently, promoting better hygiene and self-sufficiency. Additionally, the lower cost of round toilets can be advantageous when outfitting multiple bathrooms in a home.
Design and Layout
When designing or renovating a bathroom, the choice between an elongated and round toilet can influence the overall layout and flow of the space. Elongated toilets can make a statement in larger bathrooms, serving as a focal point that complements other modern fixtures. Round toilets, with their space-saving design, can help create a more open and less cluttered feel in smaller bathrooms.
Making the Decision
Choosing between an elongated and round toilet ultimately comes down to your specific needs, preferences, and bathroom layout. Here are some key questions to consider when making your decision:
How much space do you have? Measure your bathroom to determine how much space you can allocate for the toilet. If space is tight, a round toilet may be the better option.
Who will be using the toilet? Consider the needs of the primary users. For adults and individuals with mobility issues, an elongated toilet may offer better comfort. For children, a round toilet might be more suitable.
What is your budget? Factor in the cost of the toilet, including potential installation fees. Round toilets tend to be more budget-friendly, but elongated toilets may offer better long-term comfort.
What style do you prefer? Think about the overall design and aesthetic of your bathroom. Choose a toilet that complements your decor and enhances the space.
Are there any accessibility needs? If accessibility is a concern, an elongated toilet that meets ADA standards may be the best choice.
Conclusion
Both elongated and round toilets have their unique advantages and considerations. Elongated toilets offer greater comfort, a modern look, and better accessibility